Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Brad Odsen, KC's avatar

The first thing they teach in mediation courses is that the mediator has to get from the issues to the underlying motivations that are driving the issues. Thta's kind of what you're advocating Prof Wesley, but getting to that is, I think, what drives much of the intractability in the opposing positions in Alberta reflected in the referendum. We hear such things as "freedom", having control of our economy and, as the rhetoric moves further to the right, benefitting Albertans, but not non-Albertans (without defing either).

The issue I have difficulty with is that the nine questions all start with a premise, for which no evidence nor explanation has been provided. They are leading questions, and are therefore invalid by any reasonable measure. They are specifically crafted to achieve the response the UCP wants, so that it can then claim it is taking actions it wants to take because of public "demand" for them to do that - even though they know what they want to do is morally, and in most instances legally, wrong.

So what is the motivation? At this point, we can only speculate, and I frankly think it highly unlikely the citizens of Alberta would ever get an honest answer to that question.

Chris's avatar

Sorry, but I don't find this to be great insight or advice.

This is not just an election or referendum on policy. A sizeable chunk of Albertans are dedicated to breaking up the country and they're not about to change their minds. Most of the narrative is based on half truths, misinformation and disinformation.

There is a heavy overlap between dedicated separatists and people who refuse vaccinations, think COVID was a hoax (or a scam), think climate change is a hoax and a garden salad of other beliefs for which there little or no evidence. These folks have lost trust in just about every institution you can name and the question is why did it happen and what can we do about it

I don't know how you have democracy when a quarter of the people (and growing) inhabit a completely separate reality.

5 more comments...

Ready for more?