Polls have just closed on Canada’s biggest-ever experiment with direct democracy: the ten-question, $130 million Alberta referendum.
According to polls, most Albertans want to feel a sense of relief that the divisiveness is over. Yet most hold out little hope for that.
With a general election less than a year away, they’re right to be skeptical.
By definition, most of us will see the results as validation of our own core beliefs about what Alberta is and can be. The mechanics of the zero-sum process dictate that the rest of us will feel a deep sense of disappointment and rejection. There’s no way of telling who’s on which side until the votes are counted.
But no matter what, Albertans will wake up tomorrow in the same province, surrounded by the same neighbours, challenged by the same problems. As we pass our fellow Albertans on the street, many of us will wonder whether they voted differently than we did. Those folks aren’t going anywhere anytime soon. And neither are you.
So, how do we move forward?
What follows is as much a note-to-self as it is a prescription for the rest of society. All of us need a reminder of the norms that have sustained our democracy over the past two centuries, and our own role in keeping it healthy. Here are some do’s and don’ts offered in that spirit.
Don’t be a sore loser (or winner).
I’ve written before (and repeatedly) about the importance of what political scientists call "loser’s consent”: the willingness of those on the losing side of a democratic contest to accept the legitimacy of the outcome no matter how strongly they disagree with it. This is one of the unwritten rules of liberal democracy and one we’ve taken for granted here in Canada.
Loser’s consent is a central pillar of our pluralist order that requires us to find ways for minorities to remain willing to participate in a political system that doesn’t always give them what they want.
Offering losers’ consent takes an immense amount of trust: that the rules are fair and that losing today doesn’t mean being permanently excluded from decisions about tomorrow.
It also means trusting that victors will treat you as adversaries to be accommodated rather than enemies to be humiliated. In other words, neither victory nor defeat is permission to abandon democratic norms or undermine democratic institutions. Both sides have obligations after a vote like this month’s referendum.
We must not tolerate attempts to undermine losers’ consent, whether by the winners or the defeated. We must demand losers’ consent and victors’ grace as the price of participating in our democracy and call out those who would deny us of them.
Don’t let anyone steal your trust.
Unfortunately, we live in an era when losers’ consent is no longer a given. Defeat at the ballot box is often met not with reflection and concession but with conspiracies. These outlandish claims sometimes emerge spontaneously from disappointed voters, but increasingly they are manufactured and disseminated by key leaders, influencers, and bots (foreign and domestic).
At the same time, victors’ grace is in depleting supply. Winners try to vanquish their opponents by further marginalizing them at a time when they may be in most need of protection or most willing to compromise.
Our minds turn to Trump’s America when we imagine these scenarios, but Alberta is not immune. Discussed below, there is a great deal of animosity between federalists and separatists. In the coming hours, days, and weeks, we will continue to encounter the same sorts of narratives that emerged over the course of the referendum campaign. Allegations of ballot tampering, fraudulent voting, administrative incompetence, and manipulated results have already been circulating for months. The Stop the Steal narrative is alive and well.
To be clear: we should take legitimate concerns about election administration seriously. Mistakes can happen, especially when an independent election agency is deprived of the resources it needs to administer a democratic exercise as complex and large as the Alberta referendum. There are processes for documenting, investigating, and correcting these mistakes, however. And there is a world of difference between:
demanding fairness and manufacturing distrust;
administrative errors and conspiracy;
delayed counts and manipulation;
unanticipated results and fraud; and
disappointment and unjust outcomes.
Keep this in mind, especially once the initial shock and disappointment subside.
Don’t get carried away.
Political scientists have long warned us about the perils of affective polarization: the tendency to dislike, distrust, and even despise people simply because they belong to a different political camp. Here are some warning signs:
Rather than simply believing that someone else’s position is mistaken, we can slip into the sense that the person holding it must be inherently wrong on a personal level (e.g., stupid, selfish, dangerous, morally corrupt).
We turn differences of opinion into matters of conviction, identity, and character.
We attribute nefarious motives to people we have never met.
We treat an entire group as though its most extreme members represent all of their views.
We see politics as a struggle between good people and evil people, rather than a disagreement among citizens about how to best build a shared future.
The further down this path we go, the greater the danger. We start with ad hominem attacks and hyperbolic language using war-like metaphors, and we end up seeing intimidation, harassment, and even violence as justifiable responses to a political disagreement. That leads us out of the realm of liberal democracy and into something much darker.
So, too, do calls for civility that aim to silence legitimate criticisms, excuse hateful conduct, or demand that people surrender their deeply held convictions in the name of unity. We must condemn dangerous ideas and behaviour, yes. But we need not condemn everyone who happens to disagree with us as irredeemable, un-Albertan, or fit for exile (literal or figurative).
Find a kernel.
If you find yourself on the losing side this week and rooting for the victor to fail entirely, whether or not they bring down the rest of society with them, that’s a bad sign.
Continued opposition and resistance is expected. In fact, it is a cornerstone of liberal democracy. But cheering on the demise of the other side at the expense of everyone else isn’t a healthy way to proceed in the aftermath of the referendum. They won for a reason, regardless of whether you agree with that reason or not. You may continue to fight them at every turn and attempt to oust them from power at the next election. But in the meantime, consider some alternatives.
In every opponent’s platform, there’s always something you can find agreement on. It may take some digging to find a common underlying grievance, or even a unique policy idea that could use some tweaking. At the very least, you can identify a way of implementing their ideas so that they don’t hurt the most vulnerable members of our community. Look for that kernel and focus on it. Look for ways to make that part of their agenda come to fruition in a way that is productive and not destructive. Hold them accountable for doing it properly.
Seek common ground in alienation.
The referendum has only deepened the divisions in Alberta society, and these rifts will not close on their own or any time soon.
Through our Common Ground research, we’ve spent years listening to Albertans in communities across this province. People do disagree about the direction Alberta should take. But there remains considerable consensus around the importance of working together to resolve our differences.
There is also common sentiment that no one — no matter who they are — feels universally heard by people who are making major decisions about their lives and livelihoods. We all feel alienated in some way, it seems.
Many Albertans have felt ignored by Ottawa, while many others feel dismissed by their provincial government; a number feel marginalized by both. People disagree about whether rural Alberta is being overlooked or overvalued, and the same goes for the cities. This alienation is not confined to our relationships with governments. Indeed, it often stems from the respect we feel from and toward others.
That is where we should start. Not with another round of referendums, where politicians get to ask us another set of questions carefully crafted to divide us into majorities and minorities. Instead, we need more opportunities to ask genuine questions of each other and our elected representatives.
Ask your own questions.
We all have people in our lives who we disagree with. No doubt, the COVID-19 pandemic and the referendum may have driven a wedge between you and them, but imagine what it would be like to sit down and have an authentic conversation with that person. You might ask… What matters most to you these days? What worries you most? What experiences have shaped your views? What do people like me misunderstand about people like you? And how can we break down those misunderstandings?
I can already see some of you jumping into the comments section. Why should I try to understand someone who doesn’t want to understand me? Why grant someone with so much privilege the privilege of engaging with me? How am I supposed to sit down with someone whose views are so utterly offensive that they challenge my very existence? And why is it up to me to build bridges with people who tore them down in the first place? Those are fair questions, and your own safety comes first before engaging in these discussions. Not everyone could or should ask them.
In an earlier article on polarization, I shared an experience from American author, Anand Giridharadas. When he encourages people to reach across political divides, critics often compare this to “hugging Nazis”.
His response was a good one: maybe don’t start with the Nazis, but can’t we begin by recognizing that not everyone who disagrees with you is a Nazi?
We all have our limits, both as individuals and communities. Some ideas and behaviours are beyond the pale, particularly when they deny others we care about their rights, dignity, or place in society. Our problem today is not that those boundaries are being drawn too broadly. Quite the opposite.
We’ve become so accustomed in Alberta to treating someone with a differing opinion as having a moral failing that many of us have lost the capacity to distinguish between healthy tension and dangerous extremism. You can be wrong without being wicked, just like they can be misinformed without being malicious. And you can both disagree on the correct answer to a referendum question without abandoning all hope of building a better future together.
This is all at the heart of pluralism, which is both a guide and goal for us in the coming weeks. Let’s not seek the absence of disagreement; that’s counterproductive in a democratic society. Instead, let’s aim for the strength to co-exist (if not appreciate) and the desire to understand (if not cooperate). Pluralism doesn’t pretend that all ideas are equally valid or that every policy position deserves a platform. It does, however, acknowledge that no single group has a monopoly on wisdom, virtue, or the right to belong — even our own.
What can we do?
So, what can each of us do in the days and weeks ahead? Again, this is as much aimed at me as it is for you reading this.
Fight, but for a better public square.
Start with vigilance. If anyone alleges electoral wrongdoing, ask for evidence. If you encounter a sensational claim, verify it before sharing. If someone in leadership declares an outcome illegitimate without proof, demand that they substantiate the allegation or withdraw it.
Embrace skepticism, but reject cynicism. Challenge anyone who insists that democracy is legitimate only when their side wins.
But remember: embarrassing someone rarely changes their mind. Give people room to reconsider their views without losing face. Try raising questions rather than accusations. Challenge leaders and bad ideas but avoid disparaging the people who follow them. Don’t share the nasty joke. Stand by your position, but don’t dehumanize or attempt to marginalize the person. Don’t cheer when they are threatened or intimidated; don’t excuse behaviour from your own political camp that you would condemn in the other.
Talk to someone who voted differently from you.
If elections aren’t a time to discuss policy, referendums are even less so. Once the dust settles, though, it’s a good time to sit down face-to-face with someone who cast their ballots differently than you. Don’t seek out the loudmouth on social media. But perhaps a neighbour who had a different sign on their lawn or balcony, or a colleague, friend, or relative who made a surprising comment during the campaign.
If you don’t understand why they think the way they do, that’s not their fault. It’s on you. Now that the campaign is over, you can ask questions to understand, not to persuade.
Things like “what led you to your decision?” or “what are you hoping or afraid might happen next?” Listen long enough to understand the responses without thinking about how to rebut, and repeat back what you’ve heard to validate your impression. Look for shared concerns, not shared positions. You might disagree on the course of action but share the same underlying concerns about the situation. Be curious.
One conversation won’t heal a political divide, but repeated conversations can change how we see each other. They can replace assumptions and caricatures with understanding and actual people. Imagine what might happen if more Albertans approached politics that way. We could build civic muscle. And we could model the way for our representatives.
Instead of demanding that our governments listen only to people like us, we could instead insist that they listen to all of us. But only once we start listening to each other.
We can’t reasonably expect politicians to practice this sort of pluralism if we are unwilling to demonstrate it ourselves. Put another way, we can’t rebuild trust in our democratic institutions without first rebuilding some measure of it in one another.
The voting may be done, but — as always — the hardest part of democracy is the day after. We need to find a way to win and lose, and still move on together.


The first thing they teach in mediation courses is that the mediator has to get from the issues to the underlying motivations that are driving the issues. Thta's kind of what you're advocating Prof Wesley, but getting to that is, I think, what drives much of the intractability in the opposing positions in Alberta reflected in the referendum. We hear such things as "freedom", having control of our economy and, as the rhetoric moves further to the right, benefitting Albertans, but not non-Albertans (without defing either).
The issue I have difficulty with is that the nine questions all start with a premise, for which no evidence nor explanation has been provided. They are leading questions, and are therefore invalid by any reasonable measure. They are specifically crafted to achieve the response the UCP wants, so that it can then claim it is taking actions it wants to take because of public "demand" for them to do that - even though they know what they want to do is morally, and in most instances legally, wrong.
So what is the motivation? At this point, we can only speculate, and I frankly think it highly unlikely the citizens of Alberta would ever get an honest answer to that question.
Sorry, but I don't find this to be great insight or advice.
This is not just an election or referendum on policy. A sizeable chunk of Albertans are dedicated to breaking up the country and they're not about to change their minds. Most of the narrative is based on half truths, misinformation and disinformation.
There is a heavy overlap between dedicated separatists and people who refuse vaccinations, think COVID was a hoax (or a scam), think climate change is a hoax and a garden salad of other beliefs for which there little or no evidence. These folks have lost trust in just about every institution you can name and the question is why did it happen and what can we do about it
I don't know how you have democracy when a quarter of the people (and growing) inhabit a completely separate reality.